As I was gathering information for my recent post Our Contaminated World: Making Nature Illegal, I ran across and bookmarked this website, The Who Farm, which hoped to encourage the White House to plan an organic garden.
Imagine my surprise to see Michelle Obama actually breaking ground the other day, to the delight of the media, a class of 5th graders and a lot of well-meaning folks out there.
Frankly the timing is suspicious considering the very hot current topic of bill HR 875. This bill, otherwise known as The Food Safety Modernization Act of 2009, was introduced by Congresswoman Rosa DeLauro, D-Conn., in February. Her husband is Stanley Greenburg, who works for Monsanto, wouldntcha know. This bill threatens the very legality of organic farming, and the outcry is far and loud across the less mainstream Internet. Here is one typical discussion, but one can find raised hackles all over the place.
So is this Obama family garden plot a little publicity aimed to steer the public away from the truth about the administration’s apparent position on big ag? It raised an eyebrow over at Cryptogon, and forums are quickly picking up on the hypocrisy. It seems outrageous to clamor over the wonderfulness of a White House organic garden without at least mentioning the pending bill and its surrounding controversy.
This bill is sought by the current administration in response to recent food safety issues. The tragic problem of tainted food – spinach, peanut butter, etc – is creating quite a convenient ‘solution’. Could it be just another thing to add to the list of the dialectical chess game currently being played by the Oligarchy and the powers-that-be, in order to further consolidate and empower a centralized control mechanism? Namely, and likely, the The Codex Alimentarius and its current offshoots. An interesting podcast about the Codex can be found over at Red Ice Creations with Scott Tips of the National Health Federation, which seeks to protect individual rights to use dietary supplements and alternative health therapies without government restriction. Dad 2059 has been talking about it for awhile now, and has some interesting links and discussion.
It reminds me of another recent issue of contaminated toys from China, which led to, of course, The Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act, which now requires rigorous, and expensive, testing of all materials in children’s products. While some large American toy manufacturers are seeing their sales improve due to the new regulations, smaller crafters and second hand stores are going out of business by the dozen.
The Oligarchy is slowly but surely wiping out the little guys, all in the name of safety. Wonder how it got to be that way in the first place?
One wonders about Mrs. Obama’s position on HR 875, and whether she has discussed it with the hubby. Perhaps, as Cryptogon tentatively hopes, it’s her way of speaking out against HR 875. Maybe there are some interesting discussions going on in the White House living quarters at night.
Or, perhaps it’s just a ruse. One certainly wonders what she thinks about the monster likely behind the bill, Monsanto, their terminator seed technology and the suicides of thousands of farmers around the world.
“Organic” doesn’t necessarily mean not genetically modified. Therefore one naturally also wonders if the White House will be using heirloom non-GMO seeds, and if so, whether they plan on also saving the seeds they harvest themselves, which is the irreplaceable link in the chain to true sustainable living and survival. Teaching organic farming to 5th graders without mentioning this is like leaving fractions out of math class.
And if the White House IS growing heirloom tomatoes and saving seeds, for example, I reiterate: how now, brown cow??
While the White House garden is a good thing to see, as it may encourage others to go out there and grow a few veggies themselves, it sure would be extra-refreshing to see someone there speak out on the issue of non-GMO seeds and the seemingly hypocritical bill which is well on its way to further controlling and restricting the choices and freedoms of our natural heritage.
When taxes are too high, people go hungry.
When the government is too intrusive, people lose their spirit.
Act for the people’s benefit.
Trust them; leave them alone.
Tao Te Ching # 75

This work, unless otherwise expressly stated, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 License.























Nice switch of layouts, I like the bright white. The font is good, but you could boost it up one notch in size. The header is awesome.
Really suprised to see Ms Obama start an old-school garden that wastes water, offers poor yields, promotes topsoil erosion, and reduces oxygen producing grass.
Its a shame that they didn’t read on modern gardening and install a nice square-foot garden. A square-foot garden uses 20% of the space and 10% of the water of a traditional garden, but with 100% of the yield. Not to mention they look far nicer.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m3ILWPt-tgI&feature=player_embedded
Its much easier to convince Americans to install a 3- or 4-foot box of food than the monstrosity they’re building in the South Lawn. Especially since theres no digging or tilling involved.
Also, the WH garden is not organic as it doen’t meet federal standards for organic. Use of the the term organic by the WH is likely a violation of federal law.
I think this is a step in the right direction. Promotion in agriculture and farming is a good thing for people who live in urban areas or just the people who have no idea what agriculture is. Yes, it might not be a efficient but at least it’s using the WH for something other than taking up lawn space. This is what we should be promoting. We should also start promoting farmers who are trying to support the growing organic movement:
http://www.americasheartland.org/episodes/episode_115/organic.htm
@Enlight thanks for the nice words!
@Timothy you make some great points, I appreciate your thoughts. Thanks for adding your wisdom.
@Charles Indeed it is, and we should. I hope this will open a constructive dialog about organic, and non-GMO, farming.
I agree that this is a step in the right direction, even if not a perfect one. With so many convoluted and contrasting interests in politics, especially at that level, a single perspective would never perceive a clear message.
For me, the most important thing is that the issue gets people thinking about where their food is coming from, and hence, what food they are eating. If it means one less burger served at McDonald’s, it would be worth it to me!
wow love the new title bar, very nice
We are back in the land of the living BTW will be calling you soon, we will be meandering to the beach this week
[...] The White House Organic Garden: Helpful or Hypocrisy? « Surfing … [...]
Here’s an article
claiming the Obama’s are indeed using heirloom, nonhybrid seeds in their garden. But it’s not making everyone happy: Organic White House Garden Puts Some Conventional Panties in a Twist
Isn’t it interesting what people will do for a photo op? The White House garden is just for publicity in my opinion. I have difficulty thinking the first lady will be out tending her garden on a daily basis. They could plant a garden and have staff take care of it if they just wanted to raise some vegies. No need for the media to be involved.
yes a step in the right direction for sure